Tag Archives: The Carnegie

WITCH Review

By Katrina “Kat” Reynold

WITCH presented by UC College-Conservatory of Music and The Carnegie through November 17th. I attended the Opening Night performance. 

Carson Mehlbauer as Cuddy Banks & Nikolas Gray as Frank Thorney. Photo by Mikki Schaffner Photography.

As part of its new artistic partnership with The Carnegie, UC College-Conservatory of Music (CCM) is bringing WITCH by Jen Silverman to audiences this weekend. Described as “an inventive retelling of a Jacobean drama” (aka The Witch of Edmonton), the fable debates how much souls are actually worth when hope seems lost.

Director Lindsey Augusta Mercer has gathered an impressive village to surround an equally impressive group of CCM students. Pacing of the show is strong and the aesthetics are top-notch. Scenic Design by Doug Stock is quite literally worth the price of admission alone (and mad props to Scenic Carpenters Ethan Kuchta, Jack Murphy, Nathan Neorr, and Patrick Earl Phillips for their execution of it). Excellent, detailed work is also done by Costume Designer Maria Fernanda Ortiz Lopez – she is absolutely one of my favourites in terms of costuming that I have seen in recent years. Finally, particular kudos to Fight Director Gina Cerimele-Mechley for a beautifully choreographed fight scene on stairs. Bra – freaking – va!

WITCH boasts a solid ensemble of performing artists, but this should come as no surprise to CCM fans. Starting the show off strong is Debra Najor as our titular character. Ms. Najor’s delivery of the fresh dialogue is both confident and natural. When I grow up, I’d like to play the role of Scratch – but thankfully until I do, Nico Graves’ iteration of this character will more than satiate your desires. Mx. Graves excels at the physical embodiment of a presumed evil and then just as easily shows us a charming and sensitive side few could resist – excellent work! Finally, special shout-out to Carson Mehlbauer who gives a top-notch turn as Cuddy Banks, an unlikely heir. Mr. Mehlbauer carries out his character’s roller coaster of an arc with the skill envying those of many professionals in the city and beyond. Without a doubt, you will not want to avert your eyes from him when he is present in a scene.

While placed in a very different time period WITCH is ridiculously poignant and significant today, especially in light of some very recent events. The themes of hope and enduring through tough times are ultimately relatable and the play is in turn engaging. Mx. Mercer et al have bestowed a lovely gift upon theatre-goers with this piece and I highly encourage those who were not present for its opening to try and attend before it closes this coming Sunday. What do you do when hope seems lost? For me, theatre helps.

Click here for more information about the production.

Leave a comment

Filed under Reviews

WITCH Casts a Spell at The Carnegie This Fall in Partnership with the University of Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music

The dark comedy comes to Covington November 14-17

The Carnegie and University of Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music (CCM) are joining forces this November for Jen Silverman’s WITCH.

A beguiling devil arrives in a quiet English town to bargain for the souls of its residents in exchange for their darkest wishes — unexpected passions flare, alliances are formed, and the village is forever changed. This smart modern fable explores the intricacies of temptation and resilience.

Inspired by John Ford, Thomas Dekker, and William Rowley’s 1621 drama The Witch of Edmonton, Silverman’s bold transformation of a Jacobean drama begs the question: would you know what to ask for if the Devil came knocking on your door?

“WITCH is a bold, electrifying play that shatters expectations in thrilling ways. Silverman weaves a sharp, darkly comic tale that explores temptation and power,” says Tyler Gabbard, Director of Theatre at The Carnegie. “I’m excited to launch this new partnership with CCM with this hauntingly relevant play.”

Director Lindsey Augusta Mercer returns to helm the production after staging hit productions of TICK, TICK… BOOM! and KINKY BOOTS for The Carnegie.

Samuel Stricklen, a CCM Acting professor and professional actor, plays Sir Arthur Banks. Stricklen has appeared on and off-Broadway and at regional theatres including The Old Globe, Premiere Stages, La Jolla Playhouse, The Getty Villa, Brooklyn Academy of Music, and Actors Theatre of Louisville. His tv and film credits include Law and Order, Six Degrees, The Good Wife, Mozart in the Jungle, High Maintenance, and more.

The CCM student cast includes Staylie Grace, an alumni of The Carnegie education department’s summer and after-school programs and Carson Mehlbauer, who Carnegie audiences will recognize from his turn as Ambrose Kemper in HELLO, DOLLY! earlier this year. CCM student cast members making their Carnegie debut include Nico Graves, Debra Najor, and Nikolas Gray.

Playwright Silverman is currently represented on Broadway with their new comedy, THE ROOMMATE, starring Patti LuPone and Mia Farrow.

Tickets range from $13-$35 and may be purchased by calling (859) 957-1940 or by visiting
thecarnegie.com.

PRODUCTION TEAM

  • Director – Lindsey Augusta Mercer
  • Scenic Designer – Doug Stock
  • Costume Designer – Maria Fenanda Ortiz
  • Lighting Designer – Ashton Karp
  • Sound Designer – Kaitlin Barnett
  • Asst. Director – Hannah Toronto
  • Fight Director – Gina Cerimele-Mechley
  • Intimacy Coordinator – Torie Wiggins
  • Production Stage Manager – Anika Shirvaikar
  • Asst. Stage Manager – Ali Fishbain
  • Producer – Tyler Gabbard

CAST

  • Elizabeth Sawyer – Debra Najor
  • Scratch – Nico Graves
  • Sir Arthur Banks – Samuel Stricklen
  • Cuddy Banks – Carson Mehlbauer
  • Frank Thorney – Nik Gray
  • Winnifred – Staylie Brunner
  • Understudy – Victor Brame
  • Understudy – Katie Reeser

# # #

About The Carnegie
The Carnegie is Northern Kentucky’s largest multidisciplinary arts venue providing theatre events, educational programs and art exhibitions to the Northern Kentucky and Greater Cincinnati community. The Carnegie facility is home to The Carnegie Galleries, the Otto M. Budig Theatre, and the Eva G. Farris Education Center. More information about The Carnegie is available at www.thecarnegie.com or by calling (859) 491-2030.

The Carnegie is supported by the generosity of tens of thousands of contributors to the ArtsWave Community Campaign. The Carnegie receives ongoing operating support from the Kentucky Arts Council, City of Covington, Kenton County Fiscal Courts, Carol Ann & Ralph V. Haile, Jr. Foundation, the Greater Cincinnati Foundation, and Cincinnati International Wine Festival.

Leave a comment

Filed under Press Releases

WITCH Runs Nov. 14-17

WITCH
UC College-Conservatory of Music & The Carnegie
Nov. 14-17
The Carnegie [Covington]

Cast: Staylie Grace as Winnifred, Nico Graves as Scratch, Nikolas Gray as Frank, Carson Mehlbauer as Cuddy, Debra Najor as Elizabeth, Samuel Stricklen as Arthur, Victor Brame as Understudy & Katie Reeser as Understudy

A beguiling devil arrives in a quiet English town to bargain for the souls of its residents in exchange for their darkest wishes — unexpected passions flare, alliances are formed, and the village is forever changed. The Carnegie and the University of Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music join forces to present this smart modern fable that explores the intricacies of temptation and resilience. Jen Silverman’s bold transformation of a Jacobean drama begs the question: would you know what to ask for if the Devil came knocking on your door?

  • Thu-Fri, Nov. 14-15 at 7:30pm
  • Sat, Nov. 16 at 2pm & 7:30pm
  • Sun, Nov. 17 at 3pm

Official page | Facebook event |

1 Comment

Filed under On Stage

Cast Announced for CCM’s WITCH at The Carnegie

TC_logo_newJen Silverman’s dark comedy comes to life at The Carnegie this November in partnership with the University of Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music – CCM. The cast features CCM Acting students alongside faculty member Samuel Stricklen.

A beguiling devil arrives in a quiet English town to bargain for the souls of its residents — unexpected passions flare, alliances are formed, and the village is forever changed. Silverman’s bold transformation of a Jacobean drama begs the question: would you know what to ask for if the Devil came knocking on your door?

Cast:

  • Staylie Grace as Winnifred
  • Nico Graves as Scratch
  • Nikolas Gray as Frank
  • Carson Mehlbauer as Cuddy
  • Debra Najor as Elizabeth
  • Samuel Stricklen as Arthur
  • Victor Brame as Understudy
  • Katie Reeser as Understudy

Performances run Nov. 14-17.

For more information visit www.thecarnegie.com/whats-on/witch.

Leave a comment

Filed under Cast list

2025 Summer and Fall Productions Announced by The Carnegie

The Carnegie is excited to share the spectacular lineup of shows coming to the stage in Summer and Fall 2025

Witness the soul-stirring power of resilience and redemption in THE COLOR PURPLE, a beloved musical adaptation of Alice Walker’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel.

Experience a heartfelt and humorous tribute to a country music legend in ALWAYS, PATSY CLINE featuring many of Patsy’s unforgettable hits.

GREASE is the word! With its iconic songs and dazzling dance numbers, you’ll be singing and dancing in your seat.

Let’s do the time warp again! Our smash-hit production of THE ROCKY HORROR will return for an encore just in time for Halloween 2025.

Join us for a season of extraordinary theatre that celebrates the human spirit, the power of music, and the joy of storytelling. We can’t wait to see you at the theatre!

Tickets will go on sale soon.

Leave a comment

Filed under Season Announcements