MYTHIC Review

By Katrina “Kat” Reynold

Mythic presented by Cincinnati in the Park through October 19th. I attended the Opening Night performance. 

The cast of Mythic presented by Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park. Photo by Mikki Schaffner Photography.

For its Moe and Jack’s Place – The Rouse Theatre’s 2025-2026 season opener, Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park is bringing audiences Mythic with Book & Lyrics by Marcus Stevens and Music & Orchestrations by Oran Eldor. Cited as “a new pop-rock musical comedy with Broadway ambitions”, Mythic goes old-school with some Greek Mythology and presents a modern take on the tale of Persephone.

Director & Choreographer (and Tony Award-winner!) Kathleen Marshall makes use of every modicum of space in The Rouse Theatre. The action is appropriately-themed; however, the choreography distracts from the central action several times – especially when some dancers decide to put their own extra oomph into the steps. The primary rule of being in an ensemble is to be cohesive and not stand out; with some adjustments, this talented group should be able to master just that.

Mamie Parris as Demeter in Mythic presented by Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park. Photo by Mikki Schaffner Photography.

This reviewer is a sucker for lighting which complements both the action and emotion on stage and Lighting Designer Kenneth Posner knows his vocation. Along with Laser Effects Designer Adam Biscow, the use of both conventional and unconventional lighting is beautifully executed without overuse dampening either’s effect. From a luscious green landscape to the pits of Hades, the audience knows exactly where the story is taking them.

Shoutouts also due to Costume Designer Linda Cho for an aesthetically pleasing and functional wardrobe and Set Designer David Korins for successfully creating both vast and intimate spaces in the world of Greek Mythology.

It goes without saying that Mamie Parris is already a sort of goddess – so it is only fitting for her to play Demeter, the earth mother. Not only is Ms. Parris’ vocal prowess one of the best in the business, but she possesses a natural quality of likability. A true talent of her craft.

Analise Scarpaci as Persephone in Mythic presented by Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park. Photo by Mikki Schaffner Photography.

In the role of Persephone is the effervescent Analise Scarpaci. With a voice any singer and non-singer alike would envy along with what can only be described as an aura ideal to play the role, Ms. Scarpaci is simply exquisite. She gives us equal parts delicate flower and hurricane which is not an easy feat. I could listen to her sing the phonebook.

Rounding out the “main character” energy is Savy Jackson as Aphrodite (she is a powerhouse and gorgeous to boot); Michael Park as Zeus (his delivery is untouchable); and Julius Thomas III as Hades (what I wouldn’t give to have seen his turn as Alexander Hamilton – he is fire!).

While the music is catchy and impactful, the book could use more proverbial bite. The take of likening Greek Gods to modern-day celebrities is a smart one; but I do feel the play itself should be less superficial than its characters. There are hints of profound lessons and it would be just that much more memorable if the audience was witness to a deeper dive. However, Mythic is good fun with some excellent talent and worth a trip to the theatre.

Click here for more information about the production.